Topics 18-22
Part 4: The Body that Defends
One part of the Spiral Staircase reference library, the research behind the book: the topics it holds, the recommendations they grade, and the terms they define.
The chapters
- Topic 18Evidence grade: Probable. Good observational evidence with a plausible mechanism, or small or few trials.
The Immune System's Education
- Expects.
- Early years full of microbes from siblings, animals, soil, water and food, and early tastes of lifelong foods.
- Gets.
- Small families, indoor lives, fewer animals and, until recently, advice to delay allergenic foods.
5 graded recommendations · 69 sources
- Topic 19Evidence grade: Probable. Good observational evidence with a plausible mechanism, or small or few trials.
The Largest Organ
- Expects.
- Sun matched to its pigment, changing gradually with the seasons, mostly outdoors and often in shade.
- Gets.
- Pale skin under subtropical sun, dark skin at high latitudes, indoor lives and sudden, burning doses.
7 graded recommendations · 79 sources
- Topic 20Evidence grade: Probable. Good observational evidence with a plausible mechanism, or small or few trials.
The Fever and the Old Enemies
- Expects.
- Infection as the commonest threat, care from others while sick, and bands too small for crowd diseases.
- Gets.
- Crowd and herd diseases, fever treated as the enemy, work while sick, antibiotics overused and vaccines refused.
6 graded recommendations · 75 sources
- Topic 21Evidence grade: Probable. Good observational evidence with a plausible mechanism, or small or few trials.
The Pain You Were Not Supposed to Keep
- Expects.
- Injury, then a return to use while still sore, among people who help.
- Gets.
- Rest, scans that find "damage" in pain-free people, fear and, for a time, freely prescribed opioids.
7 graded recommendations · 62 sources
- Topic 22Evidence grade: Probable. Good observational evidence with a plausible mechanism, or small or few trials.
Cancer in a New Environment
- Expects.
- A body of ancestral size and lifespan; menarche in the mid-teens, many pregnancies, years of breastfeeding; no tobacco and little alcohol.
- Gets.
- Longer lives; earlier menarche, fewer and later births and shorter breastfeeding (three to four times the Dogon's menstrual cycles); excess body fat; tobacco and alcohol.
10 graded recommendations · 60 sources
The handrail for this part
All 35 graded recommendations in these 5 chapters, sorted by how strong the evidence behind each one is. How the grades work.
Strong evidence
21 recommendationsMultiple randomized controlled trials, or consistent large cohort studies with a well-understood mechanism.
- Introduce peanut and well-cooked egg early, and keep them in the diet
Under the 2017 US guidance, babies with severe eczema, egg allergy or both start peanut-containing food "as early as 4 to 6 months of age," after a clinician has considered...
Topic 18
- Take antibiotics when needed, not just in case
About 30% of US outpatient antibiotic prescriptions are likely inappropriate. Never refuse or stop a prescribed antibiotic without a clinician's advice (Chapter 20).
Topic 18
- Keep washing your hands, with plain soap
Handwashing prevents diarrheal illness. In 2016 the US Food and Drug Administration barred triclosan and 18 other antibacterial ingredients from consumer washes.
Topic 18
- Skip raw milk, worms and immune-training supplements
In the study that linked farm milk to less asthma, boiled farm milk showed no such link. Raw milk can carry Listeria, E.
Topic 18
- For long exposure, use shade, clothing and a hat, then sunscreen
When the UV index is 3 or above, Cancer Council Australia advises SPF 50 or 50+, broad-spectrum and water resistant, as "the last line of defence." Use it to prevent burning, not...
Topic 19
- Wash as often as suits you, and wash your hands always
Plain soap is enough. With eczema, seal each bath with moisturizer straight away: in a small trial in children, twice-daily baths sealed this way beat twice-weekly ones (●●○).
Topic 19
- Treat the person, not the thermometer
Use paracetamol (acetaminophen) or ibuprofen when fever makes you or your child miserable, not to hit a number. For children, give one drug at a time, not both together.
Topic 20
- Know the red flags, and call a clinician when in doubt
Get prompt medical help for a baby under 3 months with 38°C (100.4°F) or more, or 3 to 6 months with 39°C (102.2°F) or more.
Topic 20
- Vaccinate on schedule
Follow your national schedule for children and adults; if you are pregnant or have a weakened immune system, ask about live vaccines.
Topic 20
- When your back first hurts, keep going
Stay as active as pain allows. Bed rest slowed recovery, and most acute back pain settles within weeks, with or without paracetamol (acetaminophen).
Topic 21
- Skip the routine scan
Without warning signs, imaging does not improve outcomes, and "abnormal" findings are common in pain-free people of every age.
Topic 21
- Move as treatment
Choose exercise you will keep doing. In people recently recovered from back pain, a walking and education program that built up over three months to at least 30 minutes, five...
Topic 21
- Retrain the alarm
Learning how pain works does little for pain on its own. Structured treatment does more: eight weekly two-hour group sessions of CBT or mindfulness, or pain reprocessing therapy,...
Topic 21
- Use medicines safely
The World Health Organization advises against opioids as routine care for chronic primary low back pain.
Topic 21
- Don't smoke; quit at any age
Smoking causes about one US cancer in five and more than a quarter of cancer deaths.
Topic 22
- Drink less
"It is best not to drink alcohol," says the American Cancer Society. For those who do: "no more than 1 drink per day for women or 2 drinks per day for men."
Topic 22
- Limit adult weight gain
Stay in a healthy range and avoid gaining through adult life. Skip crash diets, get clinical support if you have an eating disorder, and treat weight-loss drugs as a decision for...
Topic 22
- Breastfeed if you can and want to
Each 12 months of breastfeeding, over a lifetime, lowers the relative risk of breast cancer by about 4.3%.
Topic 22
- Vaccinate against HPV
Swedish girls vaccinated against HPV (human papillomavirus) before 17 had 88% less invasive cervical cancer.
Topic 22
- Screen on time
In the US, colorectal screening starts at 45 and mammography every two years from 40 to 74; elsewhere, follow your national program.
Topic 22
- Hormone medicines
Weigh contraception and menopausal hormone therapy with a clinician; never stop a prescribed medicine without advice.
Topic 22
Probable evidence
12 recommendationsGood observational evidence with a plausible mechanism, or small or few trials.
- Let young children live with animals and play outdoors
A dog or farm animals in the first year are linked to less asthma at school age. A small Finnish pilot, not randomized, laid forest floor in daycare yards.
Topic 18
- Get short, regular, unburnt sun
When the UV index is 3 or above, a few minutes outdoors on most days keeps most people's vitamin D adequate; when it falls below 3, as in a southern Australian winter, spend time...
Topic 19
- Never burn, and protect children and teenagers most
Topic 19
- Skip sunbeds
First use before 35 is associated with 87% higher melanoma risk.
Topic 19
- Take vitamin D when the sun cannot supply it
Britain's National Health Service (NHS) suggests 10 micrograms (400 IU) a day in autumn and winter, all year with dark skin or little time outdoors, and no more than 100...
Topic 19
- Test with a reason
The Endocrine Society found no trial evidence for routine screening, even for people with dark skin, and suggests against it.
Topic 19
- Rest, drink and stay home while feverish
Rest and fluids are standard self-care, and staying home protects others. No trial shows that rest shortens a fever.
Topic 20
- Skip fever reducers "just in case" at vaccination
They blunt the antibody response. Treat a distressed child afterwards as for any fever.
Topic 20
- Use antibiotics well
Do not ask for them for colds or flu, and never take leftover or borrowed pills.
Topic 20
- Protect sleep
One sleepless night lowered pain thresholds in 25 healthy adults, and in people with both insomnia and chronic pain, CBT for insomnia improves sleep substantially and pain...
Topic 21
- Move
Aim for 150 to 300 minutes of moderate activity a week, or 75 to 150 of vigorous. The most active adults had lower risk of 13 cancers.
Topic 22
- Heed warning signs at any age
Rectal bleeding, iron deficiency anemia or abdominal pain deserve a doctor's visit. Three in four colorectal cancers under 50 are found late.
Topic 22
Emerging evidence
2 recommendationsEarly, small, animal-only, or actively contested.
- Keep people close
Laughing with friends released opioids in the brains of 12 men, and holding a husband's hand damped the brain's threat response in 16 women (Chapter 42).
Topic 21
- Night-shift workers: no proven protective step
Don't count on melatonin; in one test of 31 supplements, contents ranged from 83% below to 478% above the label.
Topic 22